If you're among the thousands of theatregoers who have been to Broadway over the past month or so, you'll likely have heard an appeal from onstage to support Broadway Cares/Equity Fights AIDS with a donation, no matter how large or small.
Please view the video, learn how Broadway Cares/Equity Fights AIDS supports over 400 local agencies across the country, and then please consider joining me in supporting this vital organization. Every little bit helps. To donate, please go here.
In keeping with the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) regulations that unfairly discriminate against bloggers, who are now required by law to disclose when they have received anything of value they might write about, please note that I have received nothing of value in exchange for this post.
This morning, it was announced that Lin-Manuel Miranda's In The Heights would close January 9, 2011, after 1,185 regular performances on Broadway. In tandem with the closing notice, it was also announced that Miranda will return to the role of Usnavi on December 25 for the last two weeks of performances.
While the Tony-winning Best Musical of 2008 has been hovering in the 60-plus percent capacity range over the last month, a story posted yesterday by The New York Times' Patrick Healy underscored the ongoing challenges In The Heights and a handful of other shows face:
Most plays need to earn 40 percent to 45 percent of their maximum possible gross to cover weekly running costs....
Other musicals that were under the 55 percent threshold last week were two shows that opened last spring, American Idiot (at a modest 39 percent) and Million Dollar Quartet (47 percent), as well as long-running hits Chicago, In the Heights, Mary Poppins, Next to Normal and West Side Story (which previously posted a closing notice for January 2).
I can't help but wonder how many of the other shows on Healy's list will post their closing notices in the weeks to come. Currently, 15 Broadway shows are scheduled to close during the month of January 2011. Although to be fair, 10 of them were only originally slated as limited runs.
This year, In The Heights resorted to stuntcasting, first with Corbin Bleu of "High School Musical" fame taking on the role of Usnavi, and more recently with "American Idol" winner Jordin Sparks joining the cast as Nina. Unfortunately, Sparks' addition hardly ignited any additional box office for the show, and she's currently set to depart the production on November 14.
Personally, I admired and certainly liked In The Heights when I saw it in April 2008, but didn't think it rose to the lofty heights of a Broadway musical. I wrote:
While Miranda & Co. deserve enormous credit for wearing their ginormous hearts on their sleeves, pants legs and virtually everything else in sight including via an impressive 11 o'clock graffiti-cum-work-of-art, I discovered even I'm capable of finding a mushy musical just a tad too treacly.
Despite the promise of something new, including Miranda's hotter than salsa hip-hop funk, In The Heights never quite soars, even with the ebullient energy infused through Andy Blankenbuehler's joyous choreography. Instead, it's a hackneyed pastiche of storytelling we've seen too many times before.
On the plus side -- and it is a huge plus -- is that In The Heights provides a significant and positive yet all too rare depiction of a slice of our Hispanic community on stage. In that respect, it remains a solid winner.
In addition to opportunities to see the show on Broadway through January 9, a touring production is winding its way through the United States and Puerto Rico through April 2011 (its next stop is Sacramento in early November).
In keeping with the new Federal Trade Commission (FTC) regulations that unfairly discriminate against bloggers, who are now required by law to disclose when they have received anything of value they might write about, please note that I have received nothing of value in exchange for this post.
Because "Great White Way" Shouldn't Be Taken Literally
Take a good look at the faces to the left.
Each is a considerable talent in his or her own right to be sure. But do you notice anything missing? Or more precisely, anyone missing?
Aside from the background hues behind many of these performers, the only real color I'm seeing is red. It's as if the brains behind BroadwaySpace.com took "Great White Way" just a little too literally when coming up with its "30 under 30" list of Broadway's hottest young actors.
Last evening, 2008's Tony Award-winning Best Musical, In the Heights earned another top entertain-ment honor -- its second of the big four. Its original cast recording won a Grammy for Best Musical Show Album.
In The Heights beat out Gypsy, South Pacific, The Little Mermaidand Young Frankenstein. As much as I preferred Gypsy and South Pacific on stage, I have to admit that In The Heights really does sound much better on CD.
Congratulations to Lin-Manuel Miranda for another huge win. Although given the thousands of Grammy categories, I'm sure even he can appreciate how dubious these awards truly are.
As noted a couple days ago, I had the enormous pleasure of taking in the American Theatre Wing's 62nd Annual Tony Awards hosted by Whoopi Goldberg on Sunday evening. And may I just state for the record that I thought Whoopi made an excellent host.
I learned so much, not only about all the behind-the-scenes work that goes into this production, but also just how much more fun actually being there can be. It's not just seeing the nominees and presenters in person, but the chance to see those amazing performances live one more time. It's also the nonstop buzz you feel from the moment you step onto the red carpet right up until you receive your Tony swag bag upon departure from the Gala.
But there are other things I learned along the way, either from personal experience or overheard from others...
...Tonys weigh more than I thought they would ... Don't bother asking Harry Potter-cum-Broadway star Daniel Radcliffe for an autograph ... It's perfectly fine to congratulate S. Epatha Merkerson on her Tony nod (she was beaming as she escorted her mother around), just please don't even think about approaching her in the ladies' room (and please don't approach me in the men's room, either) ... John Waters was really just kidding last year when he suggested he was working on a script called "Last Stall To The Left" about Senator Larry Craig ... The restrooms are "the great equalizers" at the Tonys (as I learned from my new friends Daniel and Donna from Lexington, Kentucky)...
...Not only does Gypsydirector Arthur Laurents know a thing or two about pacing a show, he's pretty fast on his feet for a man of 90 years ...The orchestra is nowhere to be seen during the Tonys, prompting the justifiable wrath of Patti LuPone during the dress rehearsals when she could not hear the music as she tried singing "Everything's Coming Up Roses" ... Speaking of dress rehearsals, only a few of the presenters were no-shows, including Alec Baldwin, Harry Connick, Jr., Laurence Fishburne and Marisa Tomei ... Could be that last star's no-show that prompted Lily Tomlin to mimic her actual appearance ... The morning rehearsals were just a tad too early for Stew, who made his feelings known as the Passing Strange troupe concluded rehearsing "Keys"...
...The ever gracious David Pittu has written a show he's getting ready to premiere at the Atlantic ... across the Atlantic, August: Osage County will make its West End debut this fall ... English actor Mark Rylance lived in my hometown of Mequon - Thiensville, Wisconsin during his formative years (since we're about the same age, I can't help but wonder if we ever met way back when) ... speaking of formative years, Keith Carradine is very proud of his progeny Martha Plimpton (he served as her Tony Awards escort, appropriate given it was Father's Day)...
...The technical Tonys were skillfully hosted by the witty, dynamic duo of Julie White and Michael Cerveris ... even Tony winning stars like White can get excited about the chance to see other stars like Connick ... thanks to Cerveris, I finally learned how to properly pronounce Les Liaisons Dangereuses... Laura Linney was gracious when at least one person told her they thought she was terrific in that play they can't pronounce ... "Project Runway" winner Christian Siriano's name was on the lips of countless young fans who were thrilled to meet him, while big stars like Glenn Close walked right on by unbothered...
...Awards do occasionally get bent, just ask Catherine Zuber ... As this year's winner for Best Costume Design for a Musical, Zuber was overheard telling someone complimenting her on her apparel choices (or lack thereof) for Matthew Morrison, "I'm no dummy" ... In person, In The Heights' Olga Merediz looks to be about half the age of Abuela Claudia, the role for which she earned her Tony nod for Best Featured Actress in a Musical ... Speaking of In The Heights, creator and lead actor Lin-Manuel Miranda looks substantially younger without his trademark ivy style cap, and he was practically floating through the Gala crowd while on Cloud 9 all evening.
Here's toasting all the nominees and winners. I'd like to thank them for a truly spectacular year on Broadway. It's one that I'll never forget.
On Tuesday, I offered what some may have thought was a pretty outrageous Tony prediction: that Xanadumight actually be benefitting from that little viral campaign and would win the Tony for Best Musical.
Of course, no one from of a pool of twelve respected prognosticators polled by the Los Angeles Times was so bold as to name Xanadu as a potential Best Musical winner among their Tony predictions. For the record, I still stand by my prediction -- and Rocco at What's Good/What Blows in New York Theatre would clearly be a very happy blogger if my soothsaying were to hold up.
Well, no sooner had I sayeth that sooth than Gil at Broadway Abridged and I began conversing about whether a spike in votes from Xanadu's campaign might actually help push Passing Strangeover the finish line.
Next thing I knew, good ol' Michael Riedel at New York Post was telling us all how close the race would be between In The Heightsand Passing Strange:
...if you look closely at your Shubert Alley tea leaves, you can discern the makings of an upset or two.
...now that I've got your attention . . . Passing Strange seems to be gaining quickly on the Best Musical front-runner, In the Heights. You hear the same thing from voters: "I think In the Heights will win, but I'm voting for Passing Strange.
The conventional wisdom was that In the Heights would triumph because (1) it's doing better at the box office and (2) being energetic and bland, it can tour the country more readily than its edgier, rougher rival.
But Passing Strange has a trump card that's been well-played: Stew, its charismatic creator and star.
He and his porkpie hat have been all over town this past month, charming pretty close to all of the 765 Tony voters. (Well, maybe not John Simon.)
Accompanying Stew on his rounds is his collaborator, Heidi Rodewald. She's very shy but has a winning personality.
Both are new to Broadway, which adds to their appeal. And it's been fun watching them befriend theater royalty such as Marian Seldes ("I adore Stew") and Edward Albee.
Well come on! With Marian Seldes in one's corner, how could it not be gaining traction among other prime voters?
UPDATE (10:35 a.m. EDT): In his column this morning, Riedel says that Passing Strange will win.
And traction is the word this morning, according to the informal polling conducted by The New York Times' Campbell Robertson, who offers that the race is indeed very close, but the last-minute surge is working:
...when it’s this close, you are wise to surrender all responsibility and bow to the math. And the poll numbers say: Passing Strange.
A well-earned tip of the hat must be paid to ModernFabulousity, who dared to go far out on a limb in predicting, on June 2 no less, that Passing Strange would win!
We doubt it. It's one thing to give the Best Musical award to a show like Spring Awakening, which is rockish and fun but is still made by people who love musical theater and Broadway. It's another thing to give the award to a show that consciously rejects Broadway tradition -- to great effect, it must be said -- written by and starring a guy who's made it clear he doesn't really care for, well, Broadway. "If you asked all of us, you could probably count the number of Broadway shows we've seen on two hands," Stew says, describing himself as a guy "you have to drag to the theater."
Contrast this to In the Heights, whose Lin-Manuel Miranda speaks enthusiastically about his love of musicals, and whose show embraces those traditions even as it spices them up with a touch of reggaeton and hip-hop. Sure, this makes the show a little more "energetic and bland," as Riedel snipes, but it also makes it a much better crowd-pleaser than Passing Strange, even if Passing Strange is more innovative a show. Argue all you want about which musical is better, but if you were a Tony voter -- that is, in most cases, a devoted Broadway lover -- which one would you vote for?
Well, Vulture, since you have asked, this devoted Broadway lover would vote for Passing Strange.
In The Heights (The SOB Review) - Richard Rodgers Theatre
**1/2 (out of ****)
First up, I'm a very sentimental man. In fact, I'm soft and gooey to the core. Some would go so far as to say I'm the epitome of a sentimental fool.
So after all that's been said about Lin-Manuel Miranda's exuberant new tuner In The Heights, I was prepared to be smitten from the get-go. I left thinking it was very likable, but a feeling of "Is that it?" persisted.
While Miranda & Co. deserve enormous credit for wearing their ginormous hearts on their sleeves, pants legs and virtually everything else in sight including via an impressive 11 o'clock graffiti-cum-work-of-art, I discovered even I'm capable of finding a mushy musical just a tad too treacly.
Don't get me wrong.
I was thrilled by Miranda's incredible backstory in which he began writing this fable while still in college. I admire his profile in perseverance as he shepherded the show, first through a successful Off-Broadway run and now on Broadway. And most of all, I am truly ecstatic that there is a profoundly positive depiction of New York's Latino life beyond the stereotypes that, quite incredibly and shamefully, a few too many critics thought was missing.
But -- and I'm sorry to say it's a big but -- despite the promise of something new, including Miranda's hotter than salsa hip-hop funk, In The Heights never quite soars, even with the ebullient energy infused through Andy Blankenbuehler's joyous choreography (making him the odds-on favorite come Tony time). Instead, it's a hackneyed pastiche of storytelling we've seen too many times before. In other words, Quiara Alegría Hudes' book dwells on the same old, same old technique.
With one notable exception, every major character -- and there are too many -- has his or her own moment in the spotlight, almost as if to make up for lost time and the depressing dearth of stage vehicles for the Hispanic community. If Lin-Manuel Miranda's hilariously named Usnavi serves as the heart of In The Heights, then Sonny, portrayed by the human sparkplug known as Robin De Jesús, is the show's very soul. So exceptional was his engaging performance, I actually felt cheated when De Jesús was denied his turn in the solo spotlight.
But ultimately, this is strictly quibbling given the absolute crowd-pleaser that is In The Heights. Thanks to its infectious beat, some knock-out numbers like the nearly showstopping "The Club/Fireworks," and impeccable cast -- including Mandy Gonzalez as struggling student Nina, Olga Merediz as the neighborhood's honorary matriarch Abuela Claudia, Andréa Burns as the saucy Daniela, and the welcome Broadway return for Priscilla Lopez as Nina's mother Camila -- Miranda serves up an impressive, earnest freshman effort.
Before I begin, please allow me to offer my humblest apologies to regular readers for being so very tardy in offering up this critics' capsule for In The Heights, as well as for completely failing to post my regular opening night feature.
I have an added omelet the size of Washington Heights on my face after receiving such a terrific, gracious nod from Modern Fabulousity over the weekend. To all of his regular readers, welcome to Steve On Broadway (SOB)!
Yesterday, the big musical Valentine to the neighborhood at the northern tip of Manhattan opened at Rialto's Richard Rodgers Theatre, after first conquering Off-Broadway last summer. Conceived and scored by Lin-Manuel Miranda, In The Heights comes to Broadway with a fresh book by Quiara Alegría Hudes and is directed by Thomas Kail and choreographed by Andy Blankenbuehler.
Singing its praises as "an uncalculated charmer," David Rooney of Variety strikes a high note: "What makes In the Heights so unique, however, is that despite the driving pulse of its Latin-American rhythms, blending hip-hop, rap, jazz, pop, salsa and merengue, this buoyant musical also nods reverently to the traditions of the show tune.... [T]he musical's plucky marriage of youthful freshness and lovingly old-fashioned craft is hard to resist. The chief criticism leveled at the show in its previous incarnation was Quiara Alegria Hudes' sentimental book, which takes a sanitized view of a close-knit group of folks in Washington Heights.... But that idealized perspective can be as endearing as it is limiting. It's a musical, after all, not a ghetto angstfest. The story's conflicts have been sharpened in the move, its emotional tensions deepened and its characters more fully shaped...."
Saluting "this scrappy little musical about chasing your dreams and finding your true home," while noting it "is Mr. Miranda’s own dream come true," Charles Isherwood of The New York Times shows remarkable enthusiasm among his criticisms: "If you stroll down to the Richard Rodgers Theater, where the spirited musical “In the Heights” opened on Sunday night, you’ll discover a singular new sensation, Lin-Manuel Miranda, commanding the spotlight as if he were born in the wings.... Directed by Thomas Kail, it is basically a salsa-flavored soap opera, and if there is an equivalent of schmaltz in Spanish, this musical is happily swimming in it.... Directed by Thomas Kail, it is basically a salsa-flavored soap opera, and if there is an equivalent of schmaltz in Spanish, this musical is happily swimming in it."
Proclaiming In The Heights as "an upbeat sweetheart of an urban folk tale," Linda Winer of Newsday is mostly complimentary: "Broadway's first Latino musical created by Latinos is a big, pulsing power-surge of a show.... But every time the middling book, by Quirara Alegría Hudes, steps over the gooey ledge of sentimentality, the crackling cast of mostly newcomers grabs back the sensibilities with one of Miranda's salsa/rap/Broadway songs or one of Andy Blankenbuehler's smart and slinky street/modern dances.... What's new is the authenticity of the immigrant stories, directed by Thomas Kail with standard Broadway types but a heartening minimum of stereotypes. And what's important is the music."
Paradoxically concluding it's "deeply flawed and deeply pleasurable," The New York Sun's Eric Grode writes why the two aren't mutually exclusive: "And so we have In the Heights," a padded, undisciplined, and almost irresistible blend of Broadway sentiment and a pan-Latino sonic hodgepodge of salsa, merengue, hip-hop, and even reggaeton. Along with director Thomas Kail and book writer Quiara Alegría Hudes, the impish composer-lyricist-star has turned this Upper Upper West Side story into, to quote one of the many dance numbers choreographed with street-smart vitality by Andy Blankenbuehler, a 'Carnaval del Barrio.' It doesn't always seem to know where it's going or why, but it makes the path look awfully tempting."
Pining for "a few people being real, nasty and maybe both, and being able to sing about it," New York Post's Clive Barnes nevertheless musters up a two-and-a-half star review: "Unfortunately, In the Heights doesn't stray more than a brief subway ride from middle-age Broadway's comfort zone.... So the music is fun, the lyrics are clever, and Miranda is the finest performer of that name since Carmen. And while no one else in the cast is at his level, or has his chances, most are pretty damn good.... There is no real plot, no true drama. Everyone is as cute as a litter of kittens."
Dismissing that this doesn't match "earlier, headier heights," Joe Dziemianowicz of New York's Daily News pffers one outright pan: "The problem is that although the show is set in Washington Heights in 2008, the creators -- Lin-Manuel Miranda (concept and songs) and Quiara Alegría Hudes (story) -- have sensibilities stuck in the 1950s. The issues and dilemmas facing the characters don't really match those of contemporary society.... What it lacks in story and believability it makes up for in a vibrant rap- and salsa-flavored score, spirited dances and great-looking design. And the cast is sweeter than dollops of dulce de leche."
I'm due to visit The Heights a bit later this month and will have my own SOB Review shortly thereafter. But in the meantime, I can picture many an advertisement blaring lots of good critical soundbites, thus ensuring that this show may be around for quite awhile.
Rain: A Tribute To The Beatles Limited run extended through May 31, 2011 (Show will go on hiatus starting January 15 and reopen at Brooks Atkinson Theatre on February 8)
Rock Of Ages - Open-ended run (Show will go on hiatus starting January 9 and reopen at Helen Hayes Theatre in March)
As someone who has been involved in both politics and public relations, it's no wonder I love watching theatre. Good or bad, it's the raw energy of seeing a live performance that gets my adrenaline pumping. From the moment I saw my very first Broadway show ("Annie" in London in 1979), I was hooked. Now I see as many as 70 shows each year ranging from soaring musicals to two-hander plays. And these eyes just may be in an audience near you!